Bull Thistle (Spear Thistle)
L. T. Kok and A. Gassmann in Driesche, F.V.; Blossey, B.; Hoodle, M.; Lyon, S.; Reardon, R. Biological Control of Invasive Plants in the Eastern United States. United States Department of Agriculture Forest Service. Forest Health Technology Enterprise Team. Morgantown, West Virginia. FHTET-2002-04. August 2002. 413 p.
Pest Status of Weed
Bull thistle, Cirsium vulgare (Savi) Tenore, is an invasive thistle from Eurasia, found throughout the United States and in Canada from Newfoundland to British Columbia. It is capable of invading fields, pastures, wastelands and along roadsides, but will not survive in cultivated fields.
Nature of Damage
Economic damage. Bull thistle occurs in overgrazed pastures, where heavy infestations can exclude livestock from infested areas. It also is common along roadside and vacant fields.
Ecological damage. Although bull thistle is a problem predominantly in disturbed areas, it also can be found in natural areas. The basal rosette may grow to nearly 1 m in diameter before bolting, and, once established, bull thistle outcompetes native plant species for space, water, and nutrients.
Bull thistle was introduced into the eastern United States several times during the 19th century. It is now established in all 48 contiguous states as well as Alaska and Hawaii (USDA, NRCS, 1999). It has been designated as a noxious weed in Maryland, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, Iowa, Oregon, and Colorado.
Background Information On Pest Plant
Bull thistle differs from Canada thistle, Cirsium avense (L.) Scop., in that leaves are pubescent on both sides, while those of Canada thistle are not pubescent on top, and may or may not be so on the underside. Flower bracts of bull thistle have spines, in contrast to those of Canada thistle. Leaves are covered with coarse hairs on the upper surface of the leaf blade, and are woolly below. Long spines extend from the leaf blade at the midrib and at each lobe. The leaf bases extend downward on the stem forming long wings.
Bull thistle is a biennial species that reproduces by seed. The root system consists of several primary roots each with several smaller lateral roots. It does not reproduce by vegetative means. Bull thistle is erect and bushy in appearance, up to 2 m high, and has many spreading branches (Fig. 1). Stems are erect, stout, often branched, and hairy. Leaves are green on the upper side, with woolly gray hairs on the underside, and end in long, pointed, yellow spines. The compact large purple flower heads (2.5 to 5.0 cm in diameter) are borne singly at the tip of a stem (Fig. 2), each producing up to 250 light straw-colored seeds. Mature plants can produce up to 4,000 seeds per plant. Bull thistle grows best on nitrogen-rich, neutral soils with moderate moisture (Klinkhamer and de Jong, 1993). It is not typically found on sand or on soils with high humus content and is absent from pure clay soils. Establishment is promoted by soil disturbance, which increases nutrient, water, and light availability to seedlings and reduces the vigor of competing vegetation (Randall, 1994). Bull thistle does not grow well in shade and drought. Phenolic acids inhibit competing plants through allelopathic effects or serve as a defense, coupled with spines, against herbivory (Klinkhamer and de Jong, 1993).
Analysis of Related Native Plants in the Eastern United States
Cirsium vulgare belongs to the tribe Cardueae (family Asteraceae), which is largely an Eastern Hemisphere group. The tribe is further divided into four subtribes (Echinopsidinae, Carlininae, Carduinae, and Centaureinae) including some 13 genera in North America (Bremer, 1994; USDA, NRCS, 1999). Only three of these 13 genera include species native to North America: (1) Centaurea (two species; subtribe Centaureinae), (2) Saussurea (seven species; assigned to the subtribe Carduinae, but the position of the genus in the tribe remains uncertain), and (3) Cirsium (subtribe Carduinae). The genus Cirsium includes about 100 native species, of which a few are threatened or endangered plants in the United States (Cirsium fontinale [Greene] Jepson var. fontinale, Cirsium fontinale [Greene] Jepson var. obispoense J. T. Howell, Cirsium hydrophilum [Greene] Jepson var. hydrophilum, Cirsium pitcheri [Torr. ex Eat.] Torr. and Gray, and Cirsium vinaceum Woot. and Standl.).
Some 20 native Cirsium species occur in the eastern United States: C. altissimum (L.) Hill, C. canescens Nutt., C. carolinianum (Walt.) Fern and Schub., C. discolor (Muhl. ex Willd.) Spreng., C. drummondii Torr. and Gray, C. engelmannii Rydb., C. flodmanii (Rydb.) Arthur, C. hilii (Canby) Fern., C. horridulum Michx., C. lecontei Torr. and Gray, C. muticum Michx., C. ochrocentrum Gray, C. nuttalii DC., C. pitcheri (Torr. ex Eat.) Torr. and Gray, C. pumilum (Nutt.) Spreng., C. repandum Michx., C. texanum Buckl., C. turneri Warnock, C. undulatum (Nutt.) Spreng., and C. virginianum (L.) Michx. (USDA, NRCS, 1999). Of these, C. pitcheri is listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act. It occurs in sand dunes along the shores of the Great Lakes in Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, and Wisconsin.
History of Biological Control Efforts in the Eastern United States
Area of Origin of Weed
Cirsium vulgare is a native of Europe, western Asia, and North Africa.
Areas Surveyed for Natural Enemies
Bull thistle was not considered a priority species when the thistle biological control program started in the early 1960s. However, it was included in the extensive surveys of natural enemies of Canada and musk thistle started in Europe in 1961 by the Commonwealth Institute of Biological Control (now CABI Bioscience), funded by Canada Department of Agriculture. Surveyed areas included southern England, France, Austria, Germany, northern Italy, and the northern part of the former Yugoslavia (Zwölfer, 1965).
Natural Enemies Found
More than 40 species have been recorded on bull thistle by Zwölfer (1965), of which 15 were reportedly broadly oligophagous on plants in the subtribe Carduinae (see Table 1 in the chapter on musk thistle). Only the seed-feeding fly, Urophora stylata Fabricius, has been selected and released for biological control of bull thistle. With the exception of T. horridus, none of the insect species released against Cirsium arvense or those used against Carduus species have been used for bull thistle.
Host Range Tests and Results
Oviposition and larval development of U. stylata were observed on the target host plant and on Onopordum acanthium L. in experimental host range studies carried out in the early 1970s. Oviposition, but no larval development was recorded on Arctium tomentosum Miller and Carduus acanthoides L. European field records include Carduus acanthoides, Cirsium arvense, Cirsium pannonicum (L.f.) Link, and Cirsium canum (L.) All. (Zwölfer, 1972).
Releases Made (from Julien and Griffiths, 1999)
Urophora stylata was released in Maryland and Washington in 1983, and was followed by releases in Colorado, Oregon, Montana, and California.
Biology and Ecology of Key Natural Enemies
Urophora stylata (Diptera: Tephritidae)
The adult fly (Fig. 3) lays eggs in the closed flower buds. Gall tissue is formed around each larva separately (Zwölfer, 1972). The gall starts to form around the immature achene and the adjacent region of the receptacle begins to swell. Mature larvae (Fig. 4) overwinter within the flowerheads of bull thistle. Pupation occurs in May and adults emerge in June.
Evaluation of Project Outcomes
Establishment of U. stylata in Maryland has not been confirmed, but this species is established in the western United States, with 60 to 90% of seed heads infested in some areas (Julien and Griffiths, 1999).
Trichosirocalus horridus has been released on bull thistle in Wyoming, but the establishment of the weevil has not been confirmed. Following initial releases on Carduus acanthoides in Virginia, some 20% of the bull thistle plants within the release areas also were exploited by this rosette weevil (McAvoy et al., 1987).
Bremer, K. 1994. Asteraceae. Cladistics and Classification. Timber Press, Portland, Oregon, USA.
Julien, M. H. and M. W. Griffiths (eds.). 1999. Biological Control of Weeds. A World Catalogue of Agents and their Target Weeds, 4th ed. Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux International,. Wallingford, United Kingdom.
Klinkhamer, P. G. L. and T. J. de Jong. 1993. Biological flora of the British Isles: Cirsium vulgare (Savi) Ten. (Carduus lanceolatus L., Cirsium lanceolatum (L.) Scop.). Journal of Ecology 81: 177-191.
McAvoy, T. J., L.-T. Kok,and W. T. Mays. 1987. Dispersal of Trichosirocalus horridus (Panzer) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) in southeast Virginia. Journal of Entomological Science 22: 324-329.
Randall, J. 1994. Biology of bull thistle, Cirsium vulgare (Savi) Tenore. Reviews of Weed Science 6: 29-50.
USDA, NRCS (U.S. Department of Agriculture, Natural Resources Conservation Service). 1999. The PLANTS Database. http://plants.usda.gov. (April, 2001)
Zwölfer, H. 1965. A list of phytophagous insects attacking wild Cynareae species in Europe. Progress Report 15. Commonwealth Institute of Biological Control, Silwood Park, Ascot, United Kingdom.
Zwölfer, H. 1972. Investigations on Urophora stylata Fabr., a possible agent for the biological control of Cirsium vulgare in Canada. Progress Report 29. Commonwealth Institute of Biological Control, Silwood Park, Ascot, United Kingdom.